Review center

Mattress reviews

49 mattresses with my GOTM ratings. Filter by type, search, or sort by any column.

Compare side by side →
Best for Trial
Saatva Classic

Luxury innerspring (coil-on-coil)

9.1 Back, Combo, Hot sleepers $1,699 365 nights Review Price
Saatva HD

Heavy-duty hybrid innerspring

9.0 Back, Heavier $3,214 365 nights Review Price
Zenhaven

Dual-sided organic natural latex

8.9 Combo, Hot sleepers $2,960 365 nights Review Price
Loom and Leaf

Memory foam

8.8 Side, Couples $2,804 365 nights Review Price
Eight Sleep Pod 6

Water-based smart cooling and heating mattress cover

8.7 Hot sleepers, Couples $2,899 30 nights Review Price
Saatva Solaire

Adjustable precision-air mattress

8.7 Couples $4,264 365 nights Review Price
Brooklyn Bedding Aurora

Cooling hybrid (foam and pocketed coils)

8.7 Hot sleepers $1,306 365 nights; returns can begin after 30 nights Review Price
Brooklyn Bedding

Hybrid (foam + pocketed coils)

8.7 Back, Combo $999 120 nights Review Price
Nolah Evolution

Luxury foam-and-coil hybrid

8.5 Side $1,480 365 nights; minimum 30-night break-in period Review Price
WinkBed

Luxury hybrid

8.5 Back, Heavier $1,499 365 nights; 30-night minimum before return or exchange Review Price
Winkbeds Ecocloud

Talalay latex hybrid

8.5 Hot sleepers — 120 nights; 30-night minimum before return or exchange Review Price
Brooklyn Bedding Sedona

Dual-coil hybrid

8.4 Back, Combo, Hot sleepers $1,959 365 nights; returns may begin after 30 nights and the trial is available once per customer Review Price
Brooklyn Bedding Spartan

Foam-and-coil hybrid

8.4 Hot sleepers $1,399 365 nights; returns can begin after 30 nights Review Price
Amerisleep AS3

Memory foam or hybrid

8.3 Side, Combo $1,249 365 nights; returns are available after the first 30 nights Review Price
Brooklyn Bedding Bowery

Copper-infused foam mattress with zoned support

8.3 Side, Back, Combo $419 365 nights; returns may begin after 30 days Review Price
Plushbeds Botanical Bliss

All-latex

8.3 Hot sleepers $1,499 365 nights; 30-night minimum Review Price
Spindle

All-latex mattress

8.3 Back, Combo, Hot sleepers — 120 nights; Spindle encourages at least 60 nights before requesting a modification or refund Review Price
EGOHOME

Hybrid or all-foam

8.2 Hot sleepers $499 100 nights (try at least 21) Review Price
Puffy

Memory foam or hybrid

8.2 Side, Back, Hot sleepers $1,049 365 nights; 30-night minimum before a mattress return Review Price
Nolah Signature 12

All-foam

8.2 Side $1,259 365 nights with a 30-night break-in period Review Price
Dreamcloud

Hybrid foam and innerspring

8.2 Back, Stomach $699 365 nights; opened-mattress returns can be requested from day 30 through day 365 Review Price
Brentwood Home

Foam and hybrid range

8.2 Side, Back, Combo $1,274 365 nights on eligible mattresses, with a required 30-night adjustment period Review Price
Nest Alexander Hybrid

Pillow-top foam hybrid

8.2 Side, Back, Stomach $1,672 365 nights; a 30-night adjustment period is required Review Price
Puffy Lux Hybrid

Memory foam hybrid

8.1 Side $1,549 365 nights; minimum 30-night adjustment period Review Price
Nolah Original 10

All-foam

8.1 Side, Back, Combo $942 365 nights; 30-night minimum break-in period Review Price
Nectar

Memory foam or foam-and-coil hybrid

8.1 Side, Back, Couples $699 365 nights; opened-mattress returns accepted from night 30 through night 365 Review Price
Bear

All-foam

8.1 Back $699 365 nights with a required 30-night break-in period Review Price
Helix

Hybrid (foam and individually wrapped coils)

8.1 Side $1,183 365 nights; 30-night minimum before a return Review Price
Layla

Flippable all-foam mattress

8.1 Side, Couples $999 120 nights; returns open after four weeks Review Price
Nest Alexander Signature

All-foam contour mattress

8.1 Side, Couples $2,122 365 nights, with a required 30-night adjustment period Review Price
Winkbeds Gravitylux

All-foam with responsive AirCell memory foam

7.9 Side, Back, Stomach $1,259 365 nights; 30-night minimum before a return or exchange Review Price
Eight

Five-layer mattress

7.9 Hot sleepers, Couples $1,799 30 nights Review Price
GhostBed

All-foam mattress

7.9 Back, Stomach $799 101 nights; return requests are accepted after 30 nights and before night 101 Review Price
Novosbed

All-foam memory foam

7.9 Combo $999 120 nights; returns are available after at least 21 nights Review Price
Personal Comfort Smart Bed

Adjustable-air smart bed

7.8 Couples $2,100 120 nights; a 45-night minimum applies Review Price
Durable

Two-sided hybrid (foam and pocketed steel coils)

7.8 Side, Back, Stomach — 100 nights; returns accepted after the first 30 nights Review Price
Propel Dual-Sided Hybrid

Flippable hybrid

7.8 Side, Back $1,999 120 nights; a minimum 30-night adjustment period is required Review Price
Molecule

All-foam mattress

7.8 Back, Hot sleepers $699 100 nights; returns may be requested after the required 30-night break-in period Review Price
Amorebeds

Foam-and-coil hybrid

7.8 Hot sleepers $856 100 nights; a 30-night minimum trial is required for free returns Review Price
Luxi

Adjustable all-foam mattress

7.8 Side, Couples $1,565 100 nights; Luxi asks customers to try the mattress for at least 21 nights Review Price
Tuft and Needle

All-foam

7.8 Side, Back, Stomach $559 100 nights Review Price
Marpac Yogabed

All-foam memory foam

7.7 Back $949 101 nights Review Price
Sapira

Memory foam and spring hybrid

7.6 Side, Back, Combo $1,599 365 nights; returns accepted from night 31 Review Price
Allswell

Hybrid mattress

7.4 Combo $282 No dedicated sleep trial; Walmart's 90-day return window applies Review Price
Wright

All-foam memory foam

7.4 Back — 120 nights Review Price
Casper

All-foam mattress

7.4 Back $1,295 100 nights; returns begin after the required 30-night adjustment period Review Price
Casper One

All-foam mattress

7.2 Stomach, Combo $799 100 nights; returns begin after a 30-night adjustment period Review Price
Leesa

All-foam memory foam mattress

7.1 Back, Couples $999 365 nights; returns begin after a 30-night adjustment period Review Price
Avenco Silence Memory Foam

All-foam mattress

7.0 Side, Back, Stomach — 100 nights Review Price

GOTM ratings are my research scores. Prices are typical sale prices for a queen (or the starting size) and change often. If you buy through my links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.